Crucial Conversations
Just What is the New Normal? Background This is the third in a series of Crucial Conversations with disabled artists. The first crucial conversation was with arts venues and organisations, presenting them with the Cultural Shift model of disabled-led practice in mainstream venues. We held a conversation about the role Access Riders can play in both easing the continued labour expected of disabled artists to explain and re-explain their access requirements to partners, venues, and commissioners. The more access riders we create, the more familiar the concept becomes to everyone, with a ripple effect towards increased accessibility in the arts. They can’t do that alone of course, but they can bring influence on the bigger picture. We also held a conversation co-hosted by legendary playwright Mark Ravenhill about the lack of legacy in print. News about that soon. All the Crucial Conversations have connecting points, and ultimately have created a space for disabled artists from all communities to talk about key matters of the inequalities and exclusion we still experience, compounded by a ‘return’ to the real world during a global pandemic. This is the report of a 90 minute conversation and is quite long. Why do we need to talk? So why is this conversation about the ‘new normal’ happening? As someone who has been shielding for two years, along with millions of other people, I have protected myself and others. However, the way the arts sector is behaving when the pandemic is still raging is just not normal. The arts are facing some of the biggest moral dilemmas in living history. Attempting to work in art and culture before the pandemic, we were a long way from reaching anything like equality for disabled practitioners. There seem to be other layers of things to consider now to avoid a two-tier arts sector. Spaces aren’t being created on big enough platforms for these conversations, with many disabled people saying that they feel silenced, ignored, guilty and worried about it affecting their careers if they speak out, so we are getting together anyway. You can still get involved This conversation is just a beginning and if you couldn’t make it along to the session it doesn’t mean you can’t contribute or get involved. You are invited to contribute responses to the questions asked during the zoom. There is more information on this here A call for allyship The responsibility is largely falling yet again onto the shoulders of disabled people to make our case. Aware of the emotional labour involved in talking about these matters in solution focussed ways, we decided to approach this conversation as reportage. And very much with a view to sharing this blog about the conversation with the wider arts world with an expectation of acknowledgement and action from publicly funded arts organisations. **Cue** – acknowledgement and action please. 1. Share this blog with a comment of support on social media, 2. Get in touch to arrange a bigger conversation, 3. Take affirmative action supported by disabled people, and 4. See this as both a learning opportunity and an opportunity to create something ground-breaking for arts and culture as we move forward. Joined up thinking strategies We need a national plan of action with suitable support for venues and organisations to develop their understanding of disability equality in practice, and to pay, largely freelance, disabled artists and practitioners for their time and expertise. We need some joined up thinking and to develop some models of excellence not exclusion! We saw for a while how the arts sector could adapt to new ways of working, learn new and relevant language, and respond to the needs of people in the pandemic. It even went a long way towards creating accessible opportunities online and disabled artists had access to people, events, and opportunities that they might not have had before. It was still far from perfect, but equality and access appeared to be finally on the agenda in many places. The voices of disabled campaigners were being heard in places that hadn’t previously listened. The return to real world events has been gradual, many venues offering social distancing and insisting on mask wearing, a handful continue to offer work online and there has been much talk of ‘new hybrid’ ways of working. And then what happened? Suddenly the ‘pandemic is over’ and we have to ‘live with it’. Millions of people are still shielding, many silenced and shouted down, many afraid to speak out as the times feel hostile to disabled people. We feel written off by the language around inevitability and we are being left behind. Many disabled people have no choice but to return to unsafe environments for financial survival or have to fight hard for safer environments. The moral dilemmas in facing the return need open discussion. There are legal obligations too. Provocation - Just what is it going to take to have an egalitarian cultural sector with the equal involvement of disabled people, reflecting our pluralistic nation? The conversation reportage The following four questions were posed for our conversation and you can read the points raised below each one. Although the comments are anonymised, it was important to us that they remain in the voices of those in the conversation. They are not exhaustive but strongly indicate that the arts sector cannot brush us into the dust under the carpet.
Everything has been gathered under headings and are presented as bullet points. It’s not scientific research but these conversations are important, and these voices need to be heard, with due consideration to the requirements of a whole community. 1. What was the old normal like for disabled artists?
2. How would you characterise the last two years (the pandemic) in terms of disabled artists experiences of the arts? What changes did you experience? Initially
Campaigning voices
Changes in access
Digital/Online
Practice
Funding and Financial Sustainability
Safety
3. What moral (and legal) dilemmas are the arts facing, or not facing, up to? Returning during a pandemic
Accountability
Penalties
Solutions
4. What do we need to fully participate – disabled audiences, participants, artists, leaders? The question is what should arts funders, decision makers and artists be thinking about to make sure those shielding and living with Long Covid can be included?
Acknowledgements – this online meeting took place on Friday 11 March 2022. A massive thank you to the disabled artists who attended this conversation: Sue, Austin, Mandy Colleran, Gareth Cutter, Honor Flaherty, Pauline Heath, Steph Robson and Tommy Watkin. Thank you to Black Robin for their separate comments for inclusion in the blog. Thank you to all the disabled practitioners having conversations like this across the country and campaigning for an equal return to the arts for disabled artists, audiences, participants and staff. Vici Wreford-Sinnott March 2022 [email protected] Funded by Arts Council England and supported by ARC Stockton. USEFUL LINKS FROM LITTLE COG Cultural Shift – Ideas for your venue and disabled people A Guide to Developing Access Riders Accessible Online Meetings Social Model, Disability Equality Ethos, Crip-Taking A guide to including disabled people in the performing arts. FROM SUE AUSTIN – Multimedia, performance and installation artist You can find out more about Sue’s work here: www.wearefreewheeling.org.uk www.immersedin360.com Review written by Aruna D’Souza having seen ‘Creating the Spectacle!’ exhibited during Radical Love Exhibition, (The Ford Institute, New York, June to August 2019): https://brooklynrail.org/2019/11/criticspage/Living-Without-Gravity Featured TED speaker - Ted talk presented at Talk of The Day on TED.com: https://www.ted.com/talks/sue_austin_deep_sea_diving_in_a_wheelchair/details?language=en Vici Wreford-Sinnott writes, "This is a call to action, as all the conversations are in this series are. Disabled Artists please develop Access Riders as tools of empowerment and activism so that they become common place, and that talk of access becomes common currency in employment and engagement in the arts. It's not the only thing we can do but it will be a part of a campaigning wave. We’re also calling for greater platforms for these conversations please. Share this information and contact us at Little Cog to discuss this further. We are being left behind at an incredible rate as the arts push forward."
This blog is written after a workshop on developing Access Riders. You can still get involved This conversation is just a beginning and if you couldn’t make it along to the session it doesn’t mean you can’t contribute comments for the 'points made' section. You are invited to contribute responses to the questions asked during the zoom. There is more information on this here Some voices are still completely missing from the arts aren’t they? It’s glaringly obvious and all of us know it, the whole arts sector I mean, but the parts that feel difficult, awkwardly shaped or like they might involve a bit too much thought are being quietly swept into the dust under carpets. It feels essential to me to create spaces where disabled artists can come together to talk where we are not silenced or hushed into embarrassment or guilt for talking about things we are still being excluded from. The important things about our experience and the spaces we feel left behind from. We see the rolling eyes and sighs – we just want to talk about the art too but there is too much in its way. There have been some huge disappointments recently as it dawns on us that only some members of our community are going to be involved in the arts going forward in current circumstances. A lot has to change. Again. Groundhog day for equality conversations. Real life exhaustion. Again. We have to ‘make a case’ and prove our worth for everything. Importantly in these conversations it is vital to note how far our community has come, the change we have campaigned for and the progress we’ve forged. The Disabled Peoples’ Rights Movement has existed for over fifty years but so few people know about this or acknowledge it. No-one is educated about it as it’s not included in any way in our education systems. It seems niche and insignificant but when we remember that 20-25% of our population consists of disabled people who experience barriers and exclusion every day, it really isn’t good enough. As a society, we still speak in hushed tones about disability as if it’s a tragedy, when in fact 70% of us will become disabled as we age as a natural part of life. It’s ridiculous that we don’t talk more about it and prepare a more accessible world. Instead, we’re still shutting people away. I was so lucky to be awarded an Arts Council England projects grant and to have continued support from ARC Stockton where I am an Associate Artist, to be able to put together my programme of Crucial Conversations and some artist development workshops in playwriting and comedy. More of them in future blogs. I have met with some incredible disabled people recently. I thrive in a safe accessible environment which is ‘disability comfortable’ and creative. I don’t live in a vacuum – ‘some of my best friends are non-disabled people’ – but I do love it when disabled people get together. It reminds me I’m part of something bigger and I’m keen to remind other disabled artists of that too. The first Crucial Conversation for disabled artists I held was about developing Access Riders. And of course it was about much more than that – reflecting on our community and its achievements, remembering we have peers and allies, and positioning the scope and scale of disability in the UK as a social phenomenon. An Access Rider is an effective tool to take control of our own access requirement communication with those we work with. We remove the ‘medical model’ perceptions that there is a list of things a disabled person ‘can’t do’ and replace it with a list of specific barriers which need to be removed to make the working environment accessible. Removing barriers has actually been the law since the Disability Discrimination Act of 1995, replaced by the Equality Act in 2010 and yet we’re still having to come up with ways to make this an expected part of the terms and conditions of working with disabled people. We are put in the position of reminding venues, organisations, funders, partners and commissioners that access is a right and not a favour. Access Riders can take a while to put together, and they do involve emotional labour in their development and sharing. They are still a relatively new tool, certainly in large numbers, but they have the potential to create ripples of knowledge on an individual level where it still feels like a form of activism to create and present one, through to being a wave of a campaign in much larger numbers. Venues and organisations cannot continue to rely on small pockets of knowledge about disability equality as they arise, often where the disabled artist ends up being free educator into the bargain. Not fair, not right and not paid. As we began the creation of our Access Riders, we discussed access at both societal and personal levels, and how this translates into art and culture settings. This is not new information to the participants in the session or to any disabled people, but it seems not to be considered by the majority in the institution that is 'the arts'. The contents of this blog are not exhaustive but are derived from a 90-minute conversation. Imagine what more we could do with greater investment. The following points were made:
So – the evidence is here. This is the additional labour for disabled artists, and this is how incredibly insightful disabled people are into wider cultural equality, involvement, and genuine pluralism. Look at this insight in a short one-off, if somewhat, Crucial Conversation. This is a call to action, as all the conversations are. Disabled Artists please develop Access Riders as tools of empowerment and activism so that they become common place and that talk of access becomes common currency in employment in the arts. It will be a part of a campaigning wave. We’re also calling for greater platforms for these conversations please. Share this information and contact us at Little Cog to discuss this further. We are being left behind at an incredible rate as the arts push forward? You can find advice on creating an Access Rider here: Little Cog Guidelines on Creating an Access Statement/Rider Acknowledgement: Thank you so much to the disabled artists who took part in this conversation. Tommy Watkin, Liz Barker, Steph Robson, Matthew Needham, Eleanor Walsh, Midnight Memphis, and Olga Macrini. Solidarity always. Thank you also to all the other disabled practitioners and disabled-led organisations promoting access statements and riders and working hard in this area. |